Hydrogenases are H2 converting enzymes that harbor catalytic cofactors in which iron (Fe) ions are coordinated by biologically unusual carbon monoxide (CO) and cyanide (CN−) ligands. Extrinsic CO and CN−, however, inhibit hydrogenases. The mechanism by which CN− binds to [FeFe]-hydrogenases is not known. Here, we obtained crystal structures of the CN−-treated [FeFe]-hydrogenase CpI from Clostridium pasteurianum. The high resolution of 1.39 Å allowed us to distinguish intrinsic CN− and CO ligands and to show that extrinsic CN− binds to the open coordination site of the cofactor where CO is known to bind. In contrast to other inhibitors, CN− treated crystals show conformational changes of conserved residues within the proton transfer pathway which could allow a direct proton transfer between E279 and S319. This configuration has been proposed to be vital for efficient proton transfer, but has never been observed structurally.