Abstract: <br> Mass-independent (nucleosynthetic) Mo isotope anomalies are uniquely useful for constraining genetic relationships among meteoritic and planetary materials and, by extension, the origin and nature of Earth's late-stage building blocks. The meaningful interpretation of such data, however, critically depends on the accurate correction of any natural and analytical mass-dependent isotope fractionation, which is commonly assumed to follow the ‘exponential law’. Here, using new high-precision Mo isotope data for a diverse set of terrestrial samples, we show that mass-dependent Mo isotope fractionation in nature typically does not adhere to this law, but is instead dominated by equilibrium and Rayleigh processes. We demonstrate that even moderate degrees of such non-exponential fractionation (i.e., mass-dependent isotope fractionation deviating from the exponential law) can result in significant spurious mass-independent Mo isotope anomalies that, when misinterpreted as nucleosynthetic anomalies, can lead to erroneous conclusions, particularly with respect to Earth's accretion history. Consequently, assessing the magnitude and origin of mass-dependent fractionation will be essential for future efforts to precisely determine the mass-independent Mo isotope composition of bulk silicate Earth and to identify potential nucleosynthetic isotope anomalies in terrestrial rocks.